Release: 19 September 2006
Label: NachoBake Records
‘Kelsey Grammer Loves Us’ is the second release from San Francisco’s Cult of Sue Todd, following last year’s ‘Nothing Noteworthy Happened Today’ EP, a six song banjo enhanced indie-folk record that quickly became one of my favourites of the year. Their often non-sensical but usually witty songs got under my skin in the way that few bands could manage. As such, ‘Kelsey Grammer Loves Us’, their first full length album, was one of the releases that I was most excited about for 2006.
Cult of Sue Todd’s website describes their sound as “anti-social songs for nervous folks”. It’s a surprisingly simple yet very appropriate description. This is the kind of band that I could imagine sitting out on their porch on rocking chairs yelling at the ‘dang kids’ to ‘get off our lawn’. But only if they didn’t look too intimidating. If you’re like me, that description alone would be enough to have me checking out a record, but I guess I should write a little more.
This is a considerably darker album than ‘Nothing Noteworthy’. While that record was made up of largely fun songs with odd flashes of cynicism, ‘Kelsey’ is almost the opposite. A darker, more paranoid sound is at the forefront here, with witty flourishes occasionally breaking through to the front. The gleefully shambolic ‘ExBoyfriends’ (mp3 below) throws us straight in at the deep end, giving us a rambling, witty and yet still grounded tale. Second song ‘Chatterbox’ opens with what should be quite depressing content: “I’ve been told that I’ve only got a year or so / So I’m writing down these stupid lines / As murky fluids fill my eyes”. The song is played with such an appropriate sense of urgency though that it never feels miserable at all.
Conversely, songs like ‘50cent’ evoke the first record with a fun, upbeat sound that sounds like the 2006 edition of previous best song ‘Burn Tampa’. Other songs like ‘Ohio2′ serve much the same purpose, and provide a welcome respite from the downbeat content on the rest of the album. Witty asides are what make these songs, like on ‘Gnome’ where lead Steven Perry sings “Make with the shitty chitchat so we can get out of here”. It’s a simple line, but one I can imagine everyone can relate to.
The instrumentation on this album is far more developed too. While the first album relied on catchy, yet relatively simplistic structures, ‘Kelsey’ isn’t afraid to experiment, at times flirting with the shambolic to the twangy upbeat banjo (’Genuflect’) and just throwing in a bit of everything (’Myth of Dirt’). The result of this is a lack of cohesion to much of the record, but an ultimately rewarding one as it’s hard to judge exactly what’s going to be played to us next.
This isn’t to say that the album is entirely without it’s flaws. ‘Nails’ drags a minute or so beyond it’s welcome, and there’s an over reliance on using vocal effects on Perry’s voice. While this works in a number of the cases, it’s a shame that his natural voice only shines through in two songs (’Fine Fettle’ and ‘17′). These are pretty minor quibbles on an otherwise very solid album though.
I spent a bunch of time before writing this debating who I could use to compare Cult of Sue Todd with, and I never really did find an answer. Beyond some instrumentation on ‘Fake Off’ that could have slid perfectly into the last Arab Strap record, there’s no one currently making music that I can really compare these guys to, which is much of the appeal to me.
Ultimately, while ‘Kelsey’ isn’t perfect, it’s still about as good as debut full-length albums get. There’s a unique sound, instrumentation that is solid without ever sounding overly practiced, and a strong songwriting talent behind it all. Assuming they keep doing what they are doing and can cross that gap to reach a larger audience, there are well deserved big things in the future of Cult of Sue Todd.
MP3 Cult of Sue Todd - ExBoyfriends Of The World (Unite And Take Over) (expired)
Pre-order Kelsey Grammer Loves Us: Insound
Cult of Sue Todd: Website || Myspace || AFoR Interview